

Mimi's Key Lime Pie

by Clayton Janette
Walking into my house with my younger sister, Olivia, my mom, Joely, and my mom’s mom, Mimi, always feels like stepping into a warm memory. Mimi is the ultimate multitasker: the best server, busser, host, chef, line cook, prep cook, dishwasher, sous chef, and executive chef all rolled into one. She does it all with ease and love. After spending her life cooking for her three kids, her skills in the kitchen are unmatched. But her talents don’t stop there—she’s also an incredible artist. Mimi’s story adds another layer to her magic. She grew up on U.S. military bases in California, Florida, Texas, and even Japan, giving her a rich and diverse perspective on life. By contrast, I’ve lived in the same house my entire life. This kitchen, though remodeled and looking completely different from how it did 20 years ago, still holds the heart of my family’s story.
It’s where laughter, learning, and love have always filled the air.
Living in the same place, surrounded by the familiarity of my comforting neighborhood, reminds me how much home truly matters.
​
My parents spend a lot of time cooking in the kitchen, and it’s a place filled with good memories. The smells wafting through the air always make me hungry, even if I’ve just eaten. My dad is usually in charge of the grill, while my mom takes on the role of “sous chef,” helping with prep and keeping everything running smoothly. The kitchen has an island at its center, perfect for chopping ingredients on the cutting boards and organizing the bowls we need for making Key Lime Pie. Our family is very close, and my grandma, who lives just five minutes down the road, visits often. When we’re all together in the kitchen, it’s always lively and full of laughter, with jokes flying around and everyone having a good time. I’ll admit, cooking and baking aren’t my strong suits, so the kitchen isn’t where I shine—but I love being there.
​
Whether I’m cleaning up dishes or sneaking bites of scraps, I always feel part of the action.
Key Lime Pie is a family favorite, and in my opinion, it’s the best dessert in the world. My grandma’s version? Unbeatable.
Key limes are small, roughly the size of a ping-pong ball, with a thin, often slightly yellowish skin when fully ripe. What truly sets them apart is their unique flavor—a bold, tangy sourness with just a hint of sweetness. This distinctive tartness makes them a favorite for a variety of recipes, both savory and sweet. While they yield less juice per fruit than regular limes, their intense flavor more than makes up for the effort. Juicing key limes can be a bit tedious due to their small size and limited juice, but the reward is always worth it.
Whether you're using them in a refreshing pie or as an addition to a savory dish, their vibrant flavor elevates any recipe.
For me, their versatility and taste make them the perfect ingredient, despite the extra effort they require. Key limes may be small, but their impact is undeniably delicious.
​
Originating from the Florida Keys, these tiny citrus gems have become an enduring symbol of the region and a cornerstone of its culinary identity. Living just 45 minutes from the Keys and visiting often has given me a deep appreciation for how key limes connect people to the tropical charm and unique spirit of Florida. While key limes are now cultivated worldwide,
their roots in the Keys remain a defining part of their story, and Florida continues to grow them with pride.
What makes key limes truly special is their journey, from a local treasure to a fruit cherished globally.
Yet, despite their international reach, they remain deeply tied to Florida’s identity. Key limes are more than just an ingredient; they’re a vibrant piece of the state’s history and a delicious reminder of its connection to the land, its culture, and the people.
​
We usually make Key Lime Pie for special occasions, whether it’s a birthday or another meaningful celebration. I especially love it when my grandma makes it for my birthday. It is so much better than a cake and feels far more special because it’s made with love from start to finish. I can already picture waking up to the smell of it baking in the kitchen, the graham cracker crust filling the house with its warm, toasty aroma. Then comes the anticipation as it cools in the fridge, signaling that the wait is almost over.
​
The scent of key lime pie brings back some of my best memories of home and family.
It’s more than just a dessert; it’s a connection to the people I love and the happy times we’ve shared. No matter where I am, whenever I taste Key Lime Pie, it instantly brings me back to those moments. It is a flavor and feeling I’ll carry with me forever.
​
To make a delicious key lime pie, you'll need a few simple ingredients: key limes, graham crackers, eggs, sweetened condensed milk, sugar, and butter.
The process is straightforward and ensures a perfect balance of tangy and sweet in every bite.
​
Start by crushing about 1 1⁄2 cups of graham crackers into fine crumbs.
Mix the crumbs with 1⁄4 cup of sugar and 6 tablespoons of melted butter until the mixture resembles wet sand.
Press this mixture evenly into the bottom and up the sides of a 9-inch pie pan.
Bake the crust in a preheated oven at 350°F (175°C) for 10 minutes, then set it aside to cool.
​
In a large bowl, whisk together three egg yolks until smooth.
Add one can (14 ounces) of sweetened condensed milk and mix until fully combined.
Squeeze enough key limes to yield 1⁄2 cup of fresh juice (about 15-20 key limes), then stir the juice into the egg mixture.
Whisk until smooth and creamy.
Pour the filling into the cooled graham cracker crust.
​
Bake the pie at 350°F for 15 minutes, or until the filling is set but still slightly jiggly in the center.
Let the pie cool to room temperature, then refrigerate for at least 3 hours or overnight.
​
Top the chilled pie with whipped cream or garnish with thin slices of key lime if desired. Serve slices chilled and enjoy your refreshing homemade key lime pie!​
Having the recipe in hand makes it feel like home is always with me, no matter where I am. The process of making the pie, squeezing the limes, stirring the filling and baking the crust, fills the space with comfort and nostalgia, even if it doesn’t smell or taste exactly the same as when she made it. The beauty of this recipe isn’t just in the pie itself but the way it carries tradition and love forward.
By recreating it, I’m not only reliving cherished memories but also honoring her and the times we shared. And maybe, as time passes, my version of the pie will take on its own magic, becoming a beloved tradition for someone else, reminding them that home is more than a place.